Can I keep my doctor with a Medicare Advantage plan?
Only if your doctor is in that specific plan's network for that specific year. Here is how to check properly, and what to do when a doctor leaves.
Sometimes yes, sometimes no, and the answer changes every January. This is the check most worth doing carefully before you enroll.
Why asking the front desk is not enough
The usual question is do you take my insurance, and the usual answer is yes. Both are too vague to rely on.
A carrier runs many different plans. A practice can be contracted with some and not others. Accepting Medicare is a different thing again from being in a specific Advantage plan's network.
Ask this instead: are you contracted with this exact plan name, for the coming plan year? Ask the billing office, not the front desk. Write down the name of who told you and the date.
Check the hospital too
A doctor in network who admits to a hospital that is out of network creates a problem you will not see coming. Ask which hospital your physician admits to, then check that hospital separately.
Same for the labs and imaging centers they refer to, if you use them regularly.
Use two sources
- Call the provider's billing office directly.
- Check the plan's own online provider directory.
- If the two disagree, trust the billing office and ask the plan to confirm in writing.
Plan directories are frequently out of date. This is a well documented industry problem, not a local one.
Networks change every year
A physician group or a hospital system can leave a plan's network at the end of the plan year. Your plan does not become a different plan, but your access does.
This is why the fall review matters even when you are happy and plan to change nothing. Check your doctors every October. See reading your Annual Notice of Change.
What if my doctor leaves mid year
This is the frustrating one. A provider leaving the network is generally not a qualifying event that lets you switch plans. You usually wait for Annual Enrollment.
Things worth asking about in the meantime:
- Continuity of care provisions, which some plans offer for a limited period when you are in active treatment
- Whether the plan will authorize continued care with that provider as an exception
- Whether another in network provider in the same group can take over
Ask the plan directly and in writing. These provisions exist but they are rarely volunteered.
If keeping a specific doctor is non negotiable
Then Original Medicare with a supplement removes the question entirely. Any provider in the country that accepts Medicare, no network, no referral, and it stays that way if you move.
That freedom costs a monthly premium. Whether it is worth it depends on how much the specific doctor matters to you. See the comparison of both approaches.
Common follow-up questions
My doctor takes Medicare. Is that the same as taking my Advantage plan?
No. These are two different things and confusing them is the most common cause of an unexpected bill. Ask about the plan by name.
What happens if I see an out of network doctor by mistake?
On an HMO the visit is usually not covered at all. On a PPO it is covered at a higher cost share. Emergencies are covered either way.
Can I switch plans if my doctor drops out mid year?
Usually not. It is generally not a qualifying event. Ask the plan about continuity of care provisions and plan to change during Annual Enrollment.
Want this looked at properly?
We are an independent agency in McAllen serving Hidalgo, Cameron and Starr counties. No cost to talk it through.
Call (956) 687-3334Read next
What is Medicare Advantage (Part C)?
Medicare Advantage